New Prop from Purple #28: FEELIN PURPLE Funding by @billzh Reply here and it will auto pop up in the proposal comment section! https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28
@kmacbeth voted For with 4 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Games ftw https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x0990d8
@billzh voted For with 2 votes on Purple #28. Reason: As the submitter of the proposal, my vote with reason is simple: LFG. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xff7182
@kevinoconnell voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x02554f
@deniz voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Really cool proposal. It's also well written and answered all my questions. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xb19da0
@ahn voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x1e2c65
@ccarella voted For with 7 votes on Purple #28. Reason: This ambitious prop onboards a new DAO, a professional sports team and its fans to Farcaster. I love the idea of bringing on a new category of interest to the network while giving the current... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xf4ceac
@kiren voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xb2178a
@seanhart voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x8a949c
@cameron voted For with 2 votes on Purple #28. Reason: This prop could be more specific in its description of intended use of funds, more tangible in terms of current audience/reach, and more tangible in stated goals, but... I'm voting FOR this b... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xc7810d
@morereese voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xac9950
@uncledavo voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Gaming's a completely new audience. Great to bring in more of this (and other subcultures) to FC. Maybe we could have parts of this app open-sourced for other communities to experiment with? https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xb59869
@jayme voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: More casts https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x508028
@jpetrich voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: This is high-upside high-risk bet for what I think is a reasonable amount given our treasury size. Good luck! https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x50f2ef
@yekim voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x5cadf0
@j4ck voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: I don't love this proposal bc it seems like 5E to build an app on top of FC for 100 users, and I don't see others getting this sort of grant. I guess they should apply lol. I am voting for bc of... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xc1c844
@gabrielayuso voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Spending 12% of the treasury on this doesn't seem reasonable to me. It's risky and the reward isn't that great IMO. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x951f13
@coulter voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x58322c
@pjs voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x017737
@scottrepreneur voted For with 2 votes on Purple #28. Reason: We are the ones who knock https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x3b00e7
@rz voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xe864ce
@evaav voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x4a9c9a
@thethriller voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Badass https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xaaab55
@phil voted Against with 5 votes on Purple #28. Reason: I am voting NO on this proposal to fund BLVCKHAND with 5 ETH. Here is what I would need to see changed to vote YES: - Reduce scope to one deliverable. Bundling a greenfield mobile app develo... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xdc7507
@ryanrodenbaugh voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x5c879a
@borodutch voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Those Who Do Not Learn History Are Doomed To Repeat It https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x3bbd65
@matthew voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: voting in favor because I think if it comes to fruition, an esports client for FC would be absolutely sick https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xfdc742
@tayyab voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Though I appreciate the in depth proposal. There is a little too much for me too chew on for a single proposal where we use 1/8 of our funds. I am generally skeptical of an effort that has ... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x762eb5
hot.neokry.eth voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: I like the ideas behind this prop but as mentioned by other voters I would like to see this broken into two distinct props. One for funding a new esports focused client and the other... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xe0a529
@royalaid voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xa3d92b
@srijan voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x7f8339
@santiago voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x76f69c
@tldr voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: 1. Large % of treasury 2. Upside depends on this community’s ability to onboard other communities in gaming space, and I don’t see evidence for that yet. 3. I’d like to use significa... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xfce6f6
@molo voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Echoing other comments: this feels like too high of a cost for unclear goals, measurements, and what honestly seems like a pretty small reach. I’ve read through it many times and I’m stil... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x9dd621
@jihad voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: I'm feeling Purple. Risky only if you consider the ETH ask in a vacuum. When you consider the plan + team, it's a no-brainer. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x6a5258
@tomwinzig voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Not enough bang for the buck https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xd95e57
@fun voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x163669
@df voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Think phil covers my concerns well. Would like to see a resubmission https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xd638b2
@pfista voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x9fd9b9
@bgrill voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: I am uncomfortable with the high proportion of treasury represented by the allocation given the N of potential new users. I would also prefer a discrete client focused prop. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xae40ae
@simmons voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Although I very much appreciate and endorse the spirit of this proposal, it's quite a large ask on a percentage basis for an unclear return of value. As is, it's trying to do too much. Ins... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x729f55
@colin- voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: ✅ I do want eSports activity on Farcaster ✅ It will be an excellent display of Eth+Social , if well implemented ✅ I like this group and their ethos, from what I can see (although webs... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x59647c
@goose voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x76d8bf
@drewbeechler voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x9d64cd
@cassie voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: This feels like a cross-branded sponsorship opportunity, but the proposal isn’t really describing that. I like the idea, but I feel it needs evidence that back the thesis https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xb69bbc
@etekis voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Not impressed by the proposal and agree with others that the ask is too large for something not really impressive. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x34a7aa
@chao voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xcc41ad
@kugusha voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x65e2bb
@wutwut voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x31f132
@davisshaver voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Proliferates protocol by exposing/onboarding new users & being example of existing community leveraging Farcaster for custom experiences. "There are many people who will always tell you n... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xfae106
@kia voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: directionally aligned with the proposal. perhaps objectively this is not a big ask but it's a large percentage of our treasury. would love to re-vote a proposal that: 1. better articulates R... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x608836
@sheldon voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Needs a revision. A lot of people articulated the sentiment and fwiw I do love the idea of integrating social into esports and gaming but in summary: without a proof of concept, any provab... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xa98728
@0xen voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: It was clarified that 1.25 ETH would be for 5-10 shirts for the team to wear. At current ETH prices that's $229 to $558 per shirt! That's some pork. Would consider voting yes without this... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x493602
@tyson voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x1d5154
dddvvv.eth voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: purple proliferation https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xf1874a
@fridaysatthepark voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xaa167c
@markfishman voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: As others have said, I’d be more comfortable passing if this was broken down into more discrete proposals and had more accountability baked in https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xca6df7
@bind voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xcf4712
@pal voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Would have loved to see more than half of a screenshot for the design of the app. The proposal made it hard to understand what was being built and how that might apply to other organizations i... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x13fbbb
@zachroth voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: glhf https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x5cddc2
@corbpage voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: I love the idea of a sponsorship. But I think we can find a better partner than this with larger reach (5400 followers on bird app). So it's a 'No' from me. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xbb025f
@chriscocreated voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: I’m pro bold experiments and making stuff happen, and have trust in the people doing it. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x719222
@branksypop voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x635196
@jameson voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Sirsu is a committed builder and BlvkHvnd has already been established as a project that can be used by esports players. A platform like Warpcaster compliments any organization’s relations... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x3e11ee
@chromuh voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xf81853
@jpren voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: This is too big of an ask for what looks like a partnership. Things that have unclear alignment and value to the DAO should be retroactively funded based on impact, and not speculated upon. ... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xe69124
@akshaan voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xe5f091
@colin voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xfde97d
@rabbit voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x6250a5
@jacky voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x4596db
@punk voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x48aa34
@forager voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Appreciate prop but feel 13% of treasury is too high of a bet without a clear ROI advancing Farcaster https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x0d44e1
@grin voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xc5510e
@rhys voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: The Success Criteria is low and too loosely defined for this level of investment https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xea23dd
@dylsteck voted For with 2 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Here’s why myself and Group Purple voted FOR. Sirsu work-shopped the proposal with many Purple members and spent hours on livestream answering questions & designing. He also has an impressi... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x619821
@maxpetretta voted Against with 2 votes on Purple #28. Reason: This is a tough decision, outlining my thoughts: + New community onboarded (gaming) + Proliferation into a physical space - Stated goal (100 users) is too low for ask - Drafts mentio... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xc6f66e
@liang voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xb5905c
@16 voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x8f4978
@andreitr voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x1baf8c
@leoclark voted For with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xb40a20
@rish voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0xf29173
@osama voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: I was trying to stay away from this proposal for two reasons: 1. I truly believe in supporting creators 2. The reaction to this proposal is unfair to the HVNDCAST team! Context: I have wor... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x8db50a
@v voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Voting No because: - it's not clear that achieving the goals will have a meaningful impact on purple / fc - it seems unlikely that 5 ETH is enough funding to develop and maintain a useful mobi... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x84808e
@off-fleek voted Against with 1 votes on Purple #28. Reason: Large and ambitious proposal (which is great) but the funds asked are a lot for purple and a little for a plan of this magnitude. Agree with others, break it down a bit more. Milestones ... https://alphacaster.xyz/dao/purple-publicgoods/prop/28/vote/0x4d565c