Advanced
Jason Goldberg @betashop
3/9/2023

Would you prefer to explicitly follow people on Farcaster or have the machine serve you up relevant content based on what you like? (keep in mind that following/followers is not in the protocol, so Farcaster apps can't just sync your follows across apps)

In reply to @betashop
Noah Bragg@nbragg
3/9/2023

I thought being able to sync your following across apps was the whole point of FC? šŸ§

In reply to @betashop
3/9/2023

BOTH? Why are the two mutually exclusive?

In reply to @betashop
Carlos MatallĆ­n@matallo
3/9/2023

1. Iā€™m very vocal against 2.

In reply to @betashop
Alex (4806.eth)@vintage
3/9/2023

I would normally want to exclusively choose who I follow, but being new here I donā€™t even know who is on the app yet. So ultimately, Iā€™m ok being served suggested follows for now but of course that creates an equality gap

In reply to @betashop
3/10/2023

I think highlights should serve up the machine and following should stay following

In reply to @betashop
Michael Pfister@pfista
3/10/2023

Definitely both. I donā€™t like the idea of getting rid of the following mechanism

In reply to @betashop
3/10/2023

I like how Reddit does it.

In reply to @betashop
Mark Carey@markcarey
3/10/2023

Interesting. I didnā€™t realize that followers were not part of the protocol. I need do a deep diveā€¦ definitely having ā€œthe machine ā€œ play a role in surfacing quality content that is relevant to me is valuable, if done well (which is the hard part, I suspect)

In reply to @betashop
Chu Ka-Cheong@kc
3/10/2023

I actually like seeing quality posts from people I didnā€™t follow on topics that I explicitly expressed interested, especially when they have opposite arguments, as long as they not clickbait or engagement farming.

In reply to @betashop
Ben Oā€™Rourke@bpo
3/10/2023

Thatā€™s what the following and highlights tab does for me - gives me the best of both worlds

In reply to @betashop
Ben Oā€™Rourke@bpo
3/10/2023

I actually prefer to make lists for different contexts

In reply to @betashop
Alex Palmer@thatalexpalmer
3/10/2023

Depends on which app Iā€™m using. Warpcast, Iā€™d rather curate the list of folks whose content I want to subscribe to (and also DC, if needed and infrequently). Other apps - Iā€™d want machine recommendation and smart search.

In reply to @betashop
welter.eth@fun
3/10/2023

explicity follow, i also limit who i follow, probably just me

In reply to @betashop
ppong.eth@ppong
3/10/2023

Both. Sometimes I look at the following tab sometimes the highlight tab

In reply to @betashop
Philippe Castonguay@phabc
3/10/2023

Just copy tiktok

In reply to @betashop
Avi šŸ’™@savvyavi
3/10/2023

Thatā€™s a tough one. Iā€™m so intentional about who I follow. But Iā€™d the machine learn my preferences the way tiktok does (or Artifact has after a month on the platform) then I would say machine. Chances are the folks I follow will be ranked there anyhow.

In reply to @betashop
Brent Fitzgerald@bf
3/10/2023

Iā€™m tired of the machine.

In reply to @betashop
Yassine Landa@yassinelanda
3/10/2023

You might want the machine to personalise both actually. Even for follow, which one you show first based on whatā€™s latest/hot/interest etc - session time might be smaller that total follow read time.

In reply to @betashop
Scott@scottw
3/10/2023

A social graph is great but only an algorithmic interest graph can truly scale. A decision about user experience. Iā€™d prefer different UIs for each.

In reply to @betashop
Ken Burbary@kenburbary
3/10/2023

Both. The discovery process isn't 100% organic IMHO.

In reply to @betashop
maurelian@maurelian
3/10/2023

OK, I see I made an over confident incorrect statement elsewhere. ļæ¼Anyways, yeah I appreciate machine suggestions, but having the ability to explicitly by decide who I follow is a matter of self determination Iā€™m not keen to give up.

In reply to @betashop
maurelian@maurelian
3/10/2023

Do you plan to make the chain algorithm transparent in some way so that I will understand how it chooses things and how I can tweak it? Thatā€™d be very web3.

In reply to @betashop
Jayme Hoffman@jayme
3/10/2023

Both

In reply to @betashop
Chris Carella@ccarella
3/10/2023

I'm in the machine feed me camp.

In reply to @betashop
Yash Karthik@yashkarthik
3/10/2023

both ....? should be clear which feed im on.

In reply to @betashop
aleena vigoda@aleena
3/10/2023

I prefer it being content forward for the serendipity of discovery (vs seeing the same ppl in new places)

In reply to @betashop
Jessica Greenwalt@littlebird
3/12/2023

I'd like a mix of both. I appreciate being served content on topics I'm interested in from folks I don't know as long as they are a reliable source.