Advanced
Mac Budkowski@macbudkowski
2/4/2023

Got mixed feelings about the Creator Economy hype. Saying "Everyone is a creator!" is like saying, "Everyone is a basketball player." It's, of course true, but just like only a few players end up in the NBA, only a few creators end up making significant money online.

In reply to @macbudkowski
Mac Budkowski@macbudkowski
2/4/2023

And although I think creating is great and people learn a lot even if they end up making $0, it's good to be honest about the odds of winning.

In reply to @macbudkowski
Adrienne 🌱@adrienne
2/4/2023

Good point. But don’t throw away the babe with the bath water. Decouple creation from economics. Promote creativity without promising $$

In reply to @macbudkowski
Alex Poon@cerberus
2/4/2023

But perhaps all you really need is 1000 true fans

In reply to @macbudkowski
David Tomu@tomu
2/4/2023

"Everyone is a creator", but not everyone monetizes, and only a few do so at a large scale, leaving only a few to define the creator economy.

In reply to @macbudkowski
ChrisCoCreated@chriscocreated
2/4/2023

agree with @cerberus and @adrienne. Creativity is a positive sum game.

In reply to @macbudkowski
Cameron Armstrong@cameron
2/4/2023

3 quick thoughts: - People tend to rise (or fall) to the expectations you set for them - Flow (not Stock) of Creators is what we should pay attention to (esp part time folk) imo - There is already enough value in the Content Economy to pay every half decent Creator a living wage, it’s just not distributed that way

In reply to @macbudkowski
abs@abs
2/4/2023

Perhaps it should just be seen as "now everyone can create", multimedia communication has been democratized.

In reply to @macbudkowski
Defiprime@defiprime
2/4/2023

Everyone could be a creator, but not every creator could find 1000 true fans.

In reply to @macbudkowski
0xen @0xen
2/4/2023

i'm convinced the 'everyone is a creator' myth was spun up in a smokey back room by apple and adobe in the early aughts to move units.

In reply to @macbudkowski
MC10 | Bankless Consulting 🎯@mc10
2/5/2023

"Everyone is a creator" is a false statement. Everyone could be a creator, but most choose the comfort of being a consumer. Becoming a creator doesn't imply ability to monetize, at all or significantly, your creations. Similarly, choosing to play basketball doesn't guarantee you'll become LeBron James. Perspective.

In reply to @macbudkowski
Donald Bullers@db
2/5/2023

Created to Become. Maybe we are all our own creators of our digital selves. Yet we’re currently segmented and separated across applications. Shift the perspective towards self-sovereignty and extract value online.

In reply to @macbudkowski
Leo Nasskau@lsn
2/5/2023

Also loads of people don't want the stress of being an independent creator / pushing to reach the nba

In reply to @macbudkowski
Azi | zo.me@azi
2/5/2023

I’m more bullish on what I call the Cooperation economy. Multiple actors within a community create value that’s distributed rather than one actor creating all the value

In reply to @macbudkowski
RedVan@redvan27
2/5/2023

i hope the creators understand this, and create for the sake and love of creating

In reply to @macbudkowski
Kush Gaikwad@honeymusket
2/5/2023

But the bar to try and actually put in the work is quite easy here, the friction is less and hence the factor of luck is quite impactful